Addictions Anonymous, 2: Self-help, Professionals And The Role of Religion
Addictions No Comments »Article by Julian I. Taber, Ph.D.,
If mental health professionals find problems with my ideas, senior members of the various Twelve Step groups may well join them in the complaint department because I suggest, in the pages to follow, some re-wording of those basic Twelve Steps.
Times and people have changed in the seventy years or so since William Wilson wrote his program for recovery in Alcoholics Anonymous. Our courts have increasingly classified Alcoholics Anonymous, and, by extension, all similar Twelve Step programs, as religious organizations. The words Godand Higher Powerappear in the steps for recovery, and meetings often begin and/or end with group prayer. The problem with this arises when professional treatment programs order their patients to attend such groups as a part of treatment. It amounts, in the eyes of the law, to enforced religious attendance, and the courts have ruled in favor of those who filed complaints.
We may not like what the federal courts decide, but it is the law. Learning to obey and respect the law, it seems to me, is fundamental to personality development and to the recovery of normal living. In the United States, we practice the separation of church and state and so, by extension, we cannot use government money to force religious participation. Fortunately, I think there is a good way out of this problem.
Powered by Qumana